Study finds no mutation shield for essential genes in bacteria and yeast
University of Bath researchers tested a hypothesis proposed in 1972 using mutation data from E. coli and baker's yeast.

Genes crucial to survival did not show lower mutation rates in two microorganisms examined by University of Bath researchers. The findings, published in PLOS Biology, challenge the hypothesis that natural selection can give essential genes extra protection against mutations.
Dr. Sofia Radrizzani and Professor Laurence D Hurst, from the university's Centre for Evolution, examined spontaneous mutations in Escherichia coli and baker's yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae. They used data from mutation accumulation experiments, which are designed to limit natural selection's influence while recording genetic changes.
The team assessed how important genes were by drawing on experiments that removed individual genes and measured the consequences. They found no relationship between a gene's importance for survival and a lower mutation rate in either organism. Three separate checks also found no evidence that natural selection had substantially biased the data.
The researchers said earlier findings could reflect the loss of harmful mutations rather than protection against them. Natural selection can rapidly eliminate damaging changes in essential genes, leaving researchers with an incomplete record of the mutations that originally occurred.
Other measures, including protein abundance and patterns of gene evolution over thousands of years, likewise offered no support for special protection, the team reported.
Mutation rates nevertheless varied with genome structure and DNA replication. Genes copied later during replication tended to accumulate more mutations. The researchers said those differences did not provide evidence of a mechanism specifically shielding essential genes.




